A forgotten strand of reception history

understanding pure semantics

Peter Olen

pp. 121-141

in: Georg Schiemer (ed), Carnap on logic, Synthese 194 (1), 2017.

Abstract

I explore a strand of reception history that follows Rudolf Carnap’s shift from a purely syntactical analysis of constructed languages to his conception of pure semantics. My exploration focuses on Gustav Bergmann’s and Everett Hall’s interpretation of pure semantics (as centered around Carnap’s notion of ’rules of designation’), their understanding of what constitutes a ’formal’ investigation of language, and their arguments concerning the relationship between expressions and their extra-linguistic referents. I argue that Bergmann and Hall strongly misread Carnap’s semantic project and, subsequently, their misunderstanding is passed down through colleagues and students (found most notably in Wilfrid Sellars’ early philosophy).

Cited authors

Carnap Rudolf

Sellars Wilfrid

Bergmann Gustav