On Tichy's determiners and Zalta's abstract objects

A. Sierszulska

pp. 486-498

in: Axiomathes 16 (4), 2006.

Abstract

It is not a common practice to postulate meaning entities treated as objects of some kind. The paper demonstrates two ways of introducing meaning-objects in two logics of natural language, Tichy's Transparent Intensional Logic and Zalta's Intensional Logic of Abstract Objects. Tichy's theory belongs to the Fregean line of thinking, with what he calls "constructions' as Fregean senses, and "determiners' as object-like meaning entities constructed by the senses. Zalta's theory belongs to Meinongian logics and he postulates a rich realm of abstract Meinongian objects to play the role of meanings. The paper analyses the mechanisms of reference in both conceptions and it offers a comparison of the mediating meaning-objects and the framework designed to expose this mediation in both theories. An attempt is made to expose how the treatment of the meaning entities depends upon the theory of meaning which is assumed.

Cited authors

Frege Gottlob