On the meaning of Hilbert's consistency problem (Paris, 1900)

Enrico Moriconi

pp. 129-139

in: Juliette Kennedy, Paul-Gabriel Sandu (eds), History of logic, Synthese 137, 2003.

Abstract

The theory that ``consistency implies existence'' was put forward by Hilbert on various occasions around the start of the last century, and it was strongly and explicitly emphasized in his correspondence with Frege. Since (Gödel's) completeness theorem, abstractly speaking, forms the basis of this theory, it has become common practice to assume that Hilbert took for granted the semantic completeness of second order logic. In this paper I maintain that this widely held view is untrue to the facts, and that the clue to explain what Hilbert meant by linking together consistency and existence is to be found in the role played by the completeness axiom within both geometrical and arithmetical axiom systems.

Cited authors

Frege Gottlob

Hilbert David